Skip to content
otworzxades.pl

XAdES vs PAdES vs CAdES

All three are EU standards for advanced electronic signatures. They differ in where the signature is stored, which decides whether you can open the document straight away.

The file never leaves your device.

.xades, .xml, .sig, .p7m, signed PDF and .zip from e-Doręczenia

  • Android
  • iPhone
  • Mac
  • Windows

The differences

  • XAdES: the signature is XML. The file ends in .xades or .xml, and the document is inside it or next to it. Devices can't open it on their own.
  • PAdES: the signature is stored inside the PDF. Any PDF app opens the document, but only some (such as Adobe Acrobat) show the signature.
  • CAdES: a binary signature in a .sig, .p7m or .p7s file. As with XAdES, the document is inside the file or next to it.

Which one is better?

None: with a qualified signature they all have the same legal effect in the EU. PAdES is easiest for the recipient because it is a normal PDF. XAdES can sign any file, including XML forms from public offices, which is why Polish systems such as ePUAP use it.

Opening them

Choose a .xades, .xml, .sig, .p7m or PDF file at the top of the page. We show the document, the signer and whether the content has been changed.

Frequently asked questions

Why can't I see the signature of a PDF on my iPhone or Mac?

The built-in PDF viewers show the content but don't check signatures. Here, or in the Otwórz XADES iPhone app, you can see who signed.

Can I turn a XAdES signature into PAdES?

Not without signing again. You can take the PDF out of the .xades file, but that copy no longer carries the signature.